From friends to collaborators? : A comparison of bilateral conflicts in the Italo-German relationship
Bitte beziehen Sie sich beim Zitieren dieses Dokumentes immer auf folgende
Institut für Politikwissenschaft
Politische Italien-Forschung : PIFO
; 06 Sprache:
Kurzfassung auf Deutsch:
The analysis demonstrated the necessity to broaden our understanding of
bilateral relations by including constructivist perspectives. In the Andreotti
and the Berlusconi case, changes on the interaction level – in the sense of
shifts from solution to escalation – are quite evident when comparing the two
empirical cases. But they do not tell much about the depth of that very change.
Going one step further, however, also in the dimension of meaning changes
in degree can be found: constructions of the relationship shift from idealistic
to rather pragmatic notions. From undisputed alliance loyalty, the "why´s"
and "how´s" of Italo-German cooperation have become more contested and
ambivalent. These results point to an enduring and substantial character of
change that has taken place, since structures of meaning are intersubjective
and hardly reducible to personality or particular circumstances. The analysis,
thus, challenges prevailing beliefs on continuity in Italo-German relations and
provides further empirical evidence in support of Rusconi´s estrangementhypothesis.
Furthermore, it refutes simplistic explanations of Italo-German difficulties as caused exclusively by an Italian Prime Minister being unpopular in Germany. In contrast, merely superficial developments are accompanied by and embedded in deeper changes in the relationship´s meaning.
Although the results of the presented case comparison convey a clear
message, they have to be treated somewhat cautiously. In the end, the analysis
was about comparing two single anecdotes, which do not (and neither aim to)
From friends to collaborators? A comparison of bilateral conflicts in the Italo-German relationship represent the total sum of Italo-German contacts. They may still serve as first illustration of the usefulness of systematic comparative analysis. However, further research has to be undertaken in order to prove whether results hold true in other settings and broader frameworks of Italo-German cooperation.
Veröffentlichungsvertrag für Publikationen ohne Print on Demand